Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Big Fish

Book: Big Fish by Daniel Wallace
Finished: February 2009
Pages: 180
Challenges:
**Winter Reading Challenge
**New Author
** 9 for 2009
** Read Your Name
** Read and Review
** tbr 2009
** 20 in 2009

First Sentence: "On one of our last car trips, near the end of my father's life as a man, we stopped by a river, and we took a walk to its banks, where we sat in the shade of an old oak tree."




Last Sentence: "No one believes a word."



This is one of those books you hear so much good stuff about that you are afraid to read it because it is so built up in your mind. I really wanted to like this book. Really. And I think now that I have been finished with it for over a week, I am removed enough from it to think about it. While reading I kept thinking, what an odd little book. I kept thinking that I really didn't like the father, or the son for that matter, too much. I kept wondering WHAT was the point? Why was I so dense that I couldn't see all the great meaning and stuff behind the stories and jokes that were told?

Now, I think the whole point is just this: At the end of the day, we all want to understand who our parents really are. We view our parents through our *child* eyes and that viewpoint is rather limited and tainted. And, sometimes, our parents don't really want us to see who they really are---don't want the good things to be scrutinized too closely for fear of exposing the not so good things.

I can say that I am glad I read the book--one week out, after pondering it awhile. I think I will rent the movie and compare the two!

7 comments:

Amy said...

I love love love the movie. I read the book after seeing the movie, and I liked it as well, but this is a rare case when I love the movie more.

Beth F said...

I loved the movie, but haven't tried the book. Maybe I'll let the book go.

Jo said...

I want to read this just because of it's title!

Nymeth said...

I love both the book and the movie. Like Amy, I watched the movie first, and when I picked up the book I was actually disappointed at first. But on a second read, I grew to love it just as much, and Daniel Wallace is now one of my favourite writers. I still think this is one of those rare occasions in which the movie is as good as the book, though. They expanded the story quite a bit, but all the additions really fit.

Ti said...

This is sort of how I feel about Things I Want My Daughters To Know. Like..what was the point? I just posted a review of it and it didn't occur to me how much I did not like it until I started to write the review for it.

I've never seen the movie Big Fish but I had no idea it was based on a book.

softdrink said...

I have read the book, but I've seen (most of) the movie. And it baffled me. Although that could be partly because it's been on tv twice and I've missed the beginning both times.

WorkingWords100 said...

Great choice for the USED portion of 9 for '09 Challenge.

Post a Comment